043: The Left Banke, ‘Pretty Ballerina’

Posted by on Sep 16, 2021 in Rock, Song Of the week |

I know I confused the universe by releasing a special Song Of the Mid-Week due to a confluence of events, but I wouldn’t want to deprive anyone of his/her/their/its Friday edition of Jeff rambling on about esoteric minutiae. So we’ll keep it short and focused. And lovely.

The Left Banke was a two-hit wonder – ‘Walk Away, Renee‘ and ‘Pretty Ballerina‘. But their two hits are indeed wonders, the most successful attempt to instill classical ingredients into art rock. In jazz, there was an entire movement in the 1950s, The Third Stream, producing quite a body of music that has held up over the years. In jazz this fusion was more serious, injecting a contemporary classical sensibility – Brubeck, the MJQ, George Russell. In rock for the most part, ‘baroque rock’, ‘Bach rock’, or (my favorite) ‘baroque & roll’ was rather pitiful and pompous, these two gems excepted.

These two songs employ baroque-ish mock-fugal lines, a quasi-harpsichord keyboard, a restrained little string section, and a light, breathy vocal. Kind of like a ‘kosher-style’ deli.

Judging by their history, The Left Banke (gee, nothing pretentious about the name, is there?) was a bunch of spoiled kids from New York. Their leader and songwriter, Michael Brown, was 16 when the group formed in 1965.  They made a few recordings which the record companies enthusiastically ignored. After the band had recorded the basic track for ‘Walk Away, Renee’, composer Brown split for the coast. The band finished up the track without him, Smash Records picked it up, and in July, 1966, it hit #5 on the Billboard Hot 100 (‘Satisfaction’ was #1), followed by ‘Pretty Ballerina’ (#15) half a year later.

They recorded one quite respectable album on which the two hits appeared. I knew it well ‘back in the day’ and recently revisited it. It’s quite pleasant, but I don’t recommend walking out of your daughter’s wedding to go look for it. If you happen upon it, it won’t hurt you. And I even performed the service of listening to the second album, a death-bed flop squeezed out of a dying band by artificial inspiration. Don’t bother.

So we’re left with the two wonder hits. Which one gets to be SoTW? Well, here were the judges’ considerations:

Walk Away, Renee’ was a bigger hit, you can hum it, you can dance to it, and it’s had more cover versions (most notably The Four Tops, which I will not understand as long as I live).

So the winner, hands down, is ‘Pretty Ballerina‘, that precious, delicate flower from December, 1966. Thanks, guys.

I had a date with a pretty ballerina
Her hair so brilliant that it hurt my eyes
I asked her for this dance
and then she obliged me
Was I surprised, yeah
Was I surprised,
No not at all

I called her yesterday,
it should have been tomorrow
I could not keep
the joy that was inside
I begged for her to tell me
if she really loved me
Somewhere a mountain is moving
Afraid it’s moving without me

And when I wake on a dreary Sunday morning
I open up my eyes to find there’s rain
And something strange within said,
go ahead and find her
Just close your eyes, yeah
Just close your eyes and she’ll be there
She’ll be there…

Tags: ,


Mark L. Levinson
Feb 27, 2015 at 11:33 am

As you may know, the pretty ballerina was Renee herself. She was the girlfriend of one of the band members, but she found it a bit disturbing when a different band member got it into his head to write songs about her.

Kevin Hodgkiss
Feb 27, 2015 at 3:21 pm

But wait! Although “Pretty Ballerina” and “Walk Away Renee” are perhaps the Left Banke’s best known tracks, I must respectfully disagree with you Mr. Jeff that we are “left with two wonder hits. “She May Call You Up Tonight” is actually my favorite Left Banke track. Jingle jangle and a chorus that won’t go away after your ears stop hearing it. And there are a few pretty cool cover versions, Richard Thompson does a soulful take, and Sid & Suzie (Matthew Sweet & Suzanna Hoffs) add Suzanne’s sweet voice to sweeten it up. Also “Barterers and Their Wives” is another worthy contender. “Desiree” is a nice effort that tries to capitalize on Renee. In fact I rather enjoy their collection “There’s Gonna Be A Storm” every once in awhile. Some cheap cheese, I’ll admit. But we all know that makes the best mac & cheese. And I like my Left Banke with a double dose of Curt Boettcher (Mr. Pop Baroque) (A possible SoTW contender….????) and Zombies. Thanks, Jeff!!!

Feb 27, 2015 at 3:45 pm

I know that first album quite well, and I agree with you that it’s uniformly very nice.
Richard Thompson covers which song?
I’ve heard “Barterers” be accused of being antisemitic, but I’m not too convinced of that.
I’ve never heard of Curt Boettcher. I shall definitely check him out.
And I’m a big Zombies fan–both of their incarnations. I even have a passing familiarity with Mssrs Argent and Blunstone’s later careers, but not too impressed. I really like their semi-raunchy early stuff. “I Love You”, “Woman”, “I Don’t Want to Know”, that stuff. I did do a blog on https://www.jmeshel.com//025-the-zombies-care-of-cell-44/

Aaron Bortz
Feb 27, 2015 at 6:06 pm

Enjoyed the post, as always. I once watched a program where Leonard Bernstein discussed contemporary music and noted the efforts of this group to use classical music in the song “Pretty Ballerina”. It appears your opinion had good company.

Kevin Hodgkiss
Feb 28, 2015 at 5:23 am

Richard Thompson does a cover of Left Banke’s “She May Call You Up Tonight”. I’m pretty sure it’s on youtube. I’ll see if I can find a link. And of course I have seen your post on “Care Of Cell 44”. I like it! Curt Boettcher produced great pop symphonies. Not necessarily “baroque” but he was responsible for “Along Comes Mary”, “Cherish” and I think (but I may be wrong..) “Windy” by the Association. He is also responsible for many of (don’t laugh…) Tommy Roe’s hits like “Sweet Pea”, “Hooray for Hazel” and “It’s Now Winter’s Day”. Silly pop songs but check out the arrangements. But if you really want to catch the genius of Curt Boettcher listen to the albums The Millennium, The Ballroom and Saggitarius “Present Tense” which includes the classic track “My World Fell Down” (which deserves SoTW status IMHO…..) Lovely arrangements that would make Brian Wilson jealous. Thanks for letting me shoot off!! Ha! Thanks, Jeff.

Kevin Hodgkiss
Feb 28, 2015 at 5:26 am

Richard Thompson~”She May Call You Up Tonight”


Kevin Hodgkiss
Feb 28, 2015 at 5:31 am

Sagittarius ~ “My World Fell Down” (Gary Usher, Curt Boettcher, Bruce Johnston, Glen Campbell….)


Feb 28, 2015 at 11:09 am

Never heard of “Pretty Ballerina”, but now that I’ve heard it… well never mind. Mother always said “if you’ve got nothing good to say – don’t say anything.”

Walk Away Renee on the other hand, I like.

Interesting sotw though. Thanks Jeff.

Feb 28, 2015 at 7:47 pm

Thanks for the leads, Kevin. Listened to Thompson’s ‘She May Call You’, quite liked it. Reminded me of The Byrds’ ‘Feel a Whole Lot Better’, which I love.
Listened to a couple of Boettchers. Can’t say I was overwhelmed. Sure, that’s a style I very much hook into, but the music didn’t get to me. I’ll take your word that it’s worth pursuing.
‘Along Comes Mary’ and ‘Cherish’ are the type of song I can understand why I swooned back then, but I can’t really go there now. However, check out this one:
I would never laugh at Tommy Roe. Anyone who so blatantly imitates Buddy Holly in 1960 (‘Sheila’/’Peggy Sue’) deserves credit for knowing which side of the Stradcaster is buttered. People were not yet realizing the magnitude of the loss. Buddy covers increased as the years went on.
Am listening to The Left Banke album now. Yeah, it’s fine, not earthshaking. There were a couple of others I grouped it with in my mind. The Cyrkle’s 2 albums (including Paul Simon’s ‘I Wish You Could be Here’). https://www.jmeshel.com//090-the-cyrkle-red-rubber-ball/
I remember The Buckinghams’ album was ok. There were one or two others cut from that same cloth (at least in my mind), darned respectable albums by 1/2/3-hit wonders.
Re the Boettcher sound–I recently revisited The Mamas and The Papas. Funny, my opinion didn’t change from all those years ago. The second album is REALLY good. Check out Even If I Could, No Salt on Her Tail, Trip Stumble & Fall, Dancing Bear. Seems to me they hold up better today than some of the aforementioned. But none of them are embarrassing. Well, maybe Tommy Roe’s other hits…
Always appreciate the feedback. Always glad to hear suggestions for SoTWs. I almost always try to pick songs where I’m really secure about the background and context, or stuff that I’m just in the glow of discovering.

Kevin Hodgkiss
Mar 2, 2015 at 2:11 am

So okay Jeff, the music nerd that I am has a playlist called Pop Symphonies and one of the songs that inspired that list was “Everything That Touches You” by the Association. Now that is a majestic song! I love how it builds to that crescendo. Two others on that list are “I Saw Her Again (Last Night)” (which in fact might be my most favorite single release ever) and “Twelve Thirty (Young Girls Are Coming To the Canyon)” by the Mama & The Papas. And I know that second album well. My dad bought that for me when I graduated Elementary School. The Cyrkle and especially The Buckinghams “Portraits” album were also favorites. Emitt Rhodes and his Merry-Go-Round” and even Spanky and Our Gang. Also on my Pop Symphonies playlist would be “God Only Knows” by the Beach Boys, “Tell It to The Rain” by the Four Seasons and even though it doesn’t quite have that big sound…”Darling Be Home Soon” by the Lovin’ Spoonful. “Five O’Clock World” by the Vogues. (Make me stop!!!) And heck, we’ve all done some things we regret, so Tommy Roe gets a pass because of his Buddy Holly connections. But keep listening to Curt Boettcher’s Millennium stuff. His albums have a great sound, lots of unusual instruments and arrangements, big choruses and hooks galore. Should have been all over the radio but left to obscurity and the preverbal cut-out bin. Love your site, thanks for allowing me to go off…and yes, it’s yours. I understand how SoTWs are chosen by you (not me) so keep doing what you’re doing. It’s fun.

Mar 2, 2015 at 2:45 am

I’m writing this because the song Trip,Stubble and Fall is mentioned in the above comments.While still in Junior High School,ABC did a “piece” on the Mama’s and the Papas recording of that song;Trip,Stubble and Fall.Now don’t get me wrong;I do like the song.But…….what I saw on TV that night didn’t resemble what winded up on their LP.The TV version was simply amazing.Now I can’t tell you the difference,I only saw the show once,but the harmonies were different and they repeated them over and over again.I was so disappointed when the album came out.Of course,now I’m used to it;it’s all I’ve g to go on.I’ve tried finding it on YouTube,but no luck.I tell anyone reading this;if you find it,you’re in for MAGIC!!!

Kevin Hodgkiss
Mar 2, 2015 at 3:46 am

Millennium ~ Sagittarius Enjoy!


Kevin Hodgkiss
Mar 2, 2015 at 3:48 am



Mar 4, 2015 at 8:58 pm

@Doug–am looking for it. That sounds very interesting, thanks.
@Kevin–I never thought of Pop Symphonies as a genre, but it does sort of make sense.
I agree about ‘I Saw Her Again’.
I’m a giant Sebastian fan, as you can see from my several postings. His ‘She is Still a Mystery’ would certainly fit in that genre, but what I love so much about the song is the music, more than Yester’s arrangement. Still, it’s divine.

Re SoTW requests—don’t get me wrong, I’m happy to hear suggestions. I’ll be happy to try to write about anything that I feel I can do justice to.

Mar 9, 2015 at 12:21 am

Jeff,if you ever find the Trip,Stubble and Fall recording sessions,please let me know.It was on a late night (10:00 p.m. slot) and ABC channel 7 (on the west coast)showed it.(I’ve an uncanny memory for things that excite me)
One more thing while I’ve got your attention;why are the comments turned off in the Buffalo Springfield piece?

Ellen G. Levitt
Sep 17, 2021 at 1:39 pm

Loved both songs but never knew there was this much history behind them and the Left Bank…wow…

Charles Siegel
Sep 17, 2021 at 4:53 pm

I always loved this song. “She May Call You Up Tonight” has also been a favorite, and I think qualifies as a hit as much as does “Pretty Ballerina.” Thanks for reminding me of these beautiful, beautiful tunes. Enjoyed the column as always.

Sep 17, 2021 at 6:30 pm

This song is also trotted out on YouTube lessons dealing with modes. It is one of the few pop songs in Lydian mode.

John Kehe
Sep 17, 2021 at 6:42 pm

When I had the privilege to design the first three ELO US releases, the PR wing of the record company was naturally heaping praise on the band, and crediting them with the invention of string-infused “classical” rock. Not so fast, thought I! Left Banke definitely beat them to that compelling combination punch. That first LB lp was much richer with treasures than two great tunes. I agree with the 2015 comments that nominate She May Call You Up Tonight as a great lost single (the endless,fussy bridge may have held it back). Every band I’ve every been in has featured that tune in our sets. The covers mentioned are admirable, but it’s a tough vocal and Brown’s version really soars. And Barterers and Their Wives had a certain droney charm, ala Fairport.Too bad they split so early – they were really into somethin’ good.

Sep 18, 2021 at 8:49 pm

Tnx muchly.

Sep 18, 2021 at 8:49 pm

Very cool.

Sep 18, 2021 at 8:51 pm

Giving the whole album a listen, although it’s already hardwired in my brain. Yes, the whole album is very enjoyable. How fortunate we were to have music like this as our backbenchers.

John Radoszewski
Jan 9, 2022 at 3:28 am

I have not looked this up but I recall that the song “Windy” was written by an
amateur female and submitted cold to The Association. This information was
included in an article in the Milwaukee Journal “Green Sheet’ probably 40 or
more years ago. Most bands don’t take songs cold in fear of getting sued later
on if parts or all of it are later recorded. They must have cut a quick deal.



Copyright © 2022 Jeff Meshel's World. All Rights Reserved.